Phonics vs Whole Language

PHONICS

WHOLE LANGUAGE
What Happens to Decoding Skills?
Ask yourself this question: what is more important, reading Shakespeare and Tolstoy, or being able to read newspapers and medical books?

 

 

Certainly we all want our children to read for enjoyment. But if children who are taught to read with mini-literature great books do not learn how to decode words, they will never be able to read newspapers or college entrance questions.
 

What Happens to Reading Skills?
Without the decoding skills of phonics, a child must rely on the remainder of the sentence for context clues or picture clues in figuring out an unfamiliar word. The unfamiliar word will not be sounded out by the reader because the child does not have these skills.

 

 

By teaching phonics, you give to the reader the formula for sounding out unfamiliar written words that are in their spoken vocabulary, but not in their sight vocabulary. Some children are natural born readers and learn how to decode words by themselves. Unfortunately, not many children are natural born readers.
 

What Happens To Spelling Skills?
By removing phonics from spelling, children must use memory skills for each word versus applying rules for over 80% of the English Language. For example, by failing to teach the "ou" sound, children do not have the formula for spelling loud, round, mouth, trouble, count.

 

 

If a teacher uses spelling words from a science unit, i.e., crustacean, currents, pollution, camouflage, oceanographer, then the student must memorize each word versus learning a formula for phonetic values. In a phonics classroom these might be the words for the week: proud, round, mouth, trough, loud, ground.

Yes, children can memorize the science words for the week's spelling test, but will they be able to spell the word's next week?

By learning a few phonic rules, students become improved readers and spellers.
 
 

Phonics CD ROM | Dyslexia_Resources


 
 
Copyright © Learn Phonics / Will Read™ 1998 - 2004. All rights reserved.
Last updated: Sunday, June 07, 2009 06:37:33 PM EDT
Questions or comments? Contact our Webmaster.